We are now selling at the Scarsdale Farmer's Market Sundays 9-2. We will be in Peekskill on 11/19 again.


Satisfy Your Sweet Cravings

Explore my exquisite selection of homemade cookies, baked with care and passion.

Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, and Diabetic Options Available on Request

As a home-based bakery, I take great care to accommodate allergen-sensitive needs. However, please note that while I strive to maintain a safe environment, my bakery is not allergen-free. All items may contain traces of common allergens such as wheat, tree nuts, peanuts, or seeds. Kindly inform me of any allergies when placing your order.


Our delightful cookies are priced at $2.50 each or $30 for a Baker's Dozen. Like 'Um's , and other specialty cookies begin at $3.00 each or $36 for a Baker's Dozen. If you don't see what you're looking for, please contact me. 

Cookies

Cookies
Gluten-Free Cookies
Allergy Sensitive Cookies

Cookies

Satisfied Cookie Lovers

HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMGOOD

HMMMMMMMMGOOD

04/29/2024
Pat M.

HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMGOOD

HMMMMMMMMGOOD

04/29/2024
Pat M.

Delicious! Not sure which is my favorite. 

05/01/2024
Gina Z.

Delicious! Not sure which is my favorite. 

05/01/2024
Gina Z.
Unique Treats, Made Just for You

Elevate your gifting game with It Must Have Been the Bake's personalized cookie service. My custom order service allows you to tailor your cookie gifts to suit any occasion, from birthdays to anniversaries to corporate events. Choose from a mouthwatering array of cookies and let me create a bespoke treat that is as unique as you are. With It Must Have Been the Bake, every cookie is a work of art, crafted with care and attention to detail to ensure a delightful experience for you and your loved ones.